How to Set Career Goals When You Don't Know What You Want

"Where do you see yourself in five years?"

It's the question that makes most professionals squirm. Not because they lack ambition, but because they genuinely don't know. They haven't figured out their "passion." They don't have a clear career destination. And every piece of traditional career advice assumes they do.

Here's the truth nobody tells you: most people don't know what they want. And that's not a character flaw or a failure of imagination. It's a perfectly reasonable response to an uncertain, rapidly changing world of work.

The good news? You don't need perfect clarity to make meaningful progress. You need a different approach entirely.

You're Not Alone (And You're Not Broken)

The Clarity Myth

We've been sold a story: successful people discovered their calling early, pursued it with single-minded focus, and achieved greatness. Steve Jobs knew he'd change the world with computers. Oprah knew she'd be in media. You should know too.

This narrative is both inaccurate and harmful. Even people with detailed career roadmaps usually built them after a period of exploration, not before.

Research tells a different story. A Gallup study found that only 27% of college graduates work in a field closely related to their major. A LinkedIn survey revealed that 58% of professionals describe their career path as "unplanned" or "accidental." Most successful people didn't follow a straight line—they zigzagged, pivoted, and stumbled into opportunities they couldn't have predicted.

Why Uncertainty Is Normal

Several factors make career clarity genuinely difficult:

The world keeps changing. Many of today's most sought-after jobs didn't exist fifteen years ago. How can you aim at a target that doesn't exist yet?

You keep changing. What excited you at 25 may bore you at 35. The career that fit your single, urban lifestyle may not fit your family-focused, suburban one. You're a moving target aiming at a moving target.

You've never been the future you. You can imagine what it's like to be a lawyer or a product manager or an entrepreneur. But you've never actually been one. Your predictions about what will make you happy are educated guesses at best.

Options overwhelm. Previous generations had fewer choices. Now, with remote work, global opportunities, and countless career paths, the abundance of options can paralyze rather than liberate.

Not knowing what you want isn't a sign you're behind. It's a sign you're human.

Why Traditional Career Advice Fails

The Problem with "Follow Your Passion"

"Follow your passion" is the most common career advice and possibly the worst.

For starters, most people don't have a pre-existing passion waiting to be discovered. Research by Stanford psychologist Carol Dweck and colleagues found that people who believe passions are fixed (found, not developed) are more likely to give up when they encounter difficulties in a new interest. Those who view passions as developed stick with challenges longer and ultimately find more fulfillment.

Passion also makes a poor compass because it confuses cause and effect. We assume people who love their work discovered the right passion. More often, they developed passion through competence, autonomy, and meaningful contribution. They didn't follow passion to mastery—mastery led to passion.

The Problem with Long-Term Planning

Traditional career planning assumes you can chart a 10-year trajectory with reasonable accuracy. Pick a destination, plot the path, execute the plan.

This worked better when careers were more predictable—when you joined a company, climbed a ladder, and retired with a pension. In today's volatile world, 10-year plans often become obsolete in 10 months.

The planning approach also assumes you know the destination. But if you don't know what you want, you can't plan your way there. You'll either choose an arbitrary goal that doesn't fit, or remain stuck in planning paralysis.

The Problem with Career Tests

Personality assessments, aptitude tests, and career quizzes promise to reveal your ideal path. Take a 30-minute test, and technology will tell you who you are and what you should do.

These tools can provide useful data points—insights into preferences, strengths, or working styles. But they can't answer the deeper questions. No algorithm can account for the specific context of your life, relationships, values, and evolving interests.

More problematically, these tests can create premature closure. You take a test, receive a result, and either force yourself into that mold or dismiss the process entirely when it doesn't resonate.

Career clarity doesn't come from tests. It comes from experiences.

The Exploration Mindset: Experiment, Don't Plan

From Planning to Prototyping

Bill Burnett and Dave Evans propose a radical alternative to traditional career planning: treat your career like a design problem.

Designers don't start with the answer. They start with the problem, generate multiple possibilities, build quick prototypes, test them in the real world, and iterate based on feedback. They embrace uncertainty as part of the process.

Applied to careers, this means:

Generate multiple possibilities. Instead of searching for the one right answer, brainstorm multiple possible directions. Burnett and Evans recommend designing three "Odyssey Plans"—three genuinely different five-year scenarios you'd be excited to live.

Prototype before committing. Before betting your career on a direction, find low-cost ways to test it. A conversation with someone in the field, a side project, a weekend workshop, a shadowing experience. Gather real data about what that path actually feels like.

Bias toward action. In design thinking, you don't figure things out by thinking harder—you figure things out by doing. Clarity comes from action, not reflection alone.

Iterate constantly. Your career isn't a decision you make once. It's an ongoing series of experiments, adjustments, and course corrections.

The Two-Year Experiment Framework

If you can't plan your whole career, what can you plan? Think in two-year experiments.

Two years is long enough to develop competence, build relationships, and generate meaningful results. It's short enough to course-correct if things aren't working. It transforms career decisions from permanent commitments into temporary experiments.

How to use the framework:

1. Choose a direction based on your best current understanding of your values, interests, and opportunities
2. Design a two-year experiment that lets you genuinely test that direction (not a half-hearted attempt)
3. Define success criteria beyond just job title—what would you need to learn, experience, or achieve to consider this experiment valuable?
4. Commit fully for the experiment period—give it a real chance
5. Evaluate honestly at the end—what did you learn? Do you want to continue, adjust, or try something new?
6. Iterate based on what you learned—begin your next two-year experiment with better data

This isn't aimless wandering. It's structured exploration with clear timelines and evaluation criteria. You're not drifting—you're learning through deliberate experimentation.

Self-Discovery Exercises

Before you can explore directions, you need raw material to work with. These exercises help you surface the data that already exists within your experiences.

Values Clarification

Your values are your non-negotiables—the principles that, when violated, make any situation feel wrong, and when honored, make even difficult situations feel right.

The Values Hierarchy Exercise:

1. Review this list of common values (or create your own):

2. Select your top 10 values—the ones that resonate most strongly
3. Force-rank them. If you could only honor one, which would it be? Then which? Continue until you have a ranked list
4. For your top 5, write a sentence about what that value means specifically to you

Apply to Career Decisions:

When evaluating any career direction, ask:

• Which of my top values does this honor?
• Which does it violate?
• What trade-offs am I making?

No job will honor all your values perfectly. But a job that violates your top values will never satisfy you, regardless of compensation or prestige.

Skills Inventory

Skills fall into three categories:

Technical skills: The specific, teachable abilities required for a job (programming languages, financial modeling, design software, etc.)

Transferable skills: The portable abilities that apply across contexts (communication, project management, problem-solving, leadership, etc.)

Self-management skills: The personal qualities that affect how you work (resilience, adaptability, initiative, emotional regulation, etc.)

The Skills Audit:

1. List every job, project, volunteer role, and significant life experience you've had
2. For each, identify:
   • What technical skills did you use or develop?
   • What transferable skills did you practice?
   • What self-management skills did you demonstrate?
3. Star the skills where you're genuinely strong—not just competent, but better than most
4. Circle the skills you actually enjoy using—some of your strengths might bore you

The sweet spot for career direction lies where your starred skills and circled skills overlap—things you're good at and enjoy doing.

Energy Audit: What Energizes vs. Drains

Not all work is equal in terms of its effect on your energy. Some tasks leave you energized even after hours of effort. Others drain you within minutes.

Energy Audit Categories:

Don't just note what you do—note how you do it. You might love strategy but hate strategy meetings. You might enjoy writing but hate writing under pressure. The context matters as much as the content. For a deeper dive into this concept, read about why energy management matters more than time management.

The Ikigai Framework

The Japanese concept of ikigai (roughly, "reason for being") offers a holistic lens for career exploration. Your ikigai sits at the intersection of four elements:

1. What you love: Activities that bring you joy and engagement
2. What you're good at: Skills and abilities where you excel
3. What the world needs: Problems or needs your work could address
4. What you can be paid for: Skills and services that have market value

Mapping Your Ikigai:

Draw four overlapping circles. In each, list:

• Love: What activities make you lose track of time? What would you do even if you weren't paid?
• Good at: What skills have you developed? What do others consistently seek your help with?
• World needs: What problems concern you? What changes would you like to see? What needs exist in your community or industry?
• Paid for: What skills are employers seeking? What services are people willing to pay for? What's growing in demand?

Look for the overlaps:

• Love + Good at = Passion (but may not pay)

• Good at + Paid for = Profession (but may not fulfill)

• Paid for + World needs = Vocation (but may not engage you)

• World needs + Love = Mission (but may not sustain you financially)

• All four = Ikigai

You may not find perfect overlap immediately. The exercise reveals gaps: perhaps you love something but haven't developed skills yet. Perhaps you have skills but no market for them. These gaps become development priorities.

Setting "Directional" Goals vs. Specific Destinations

Why Traditional Goals Fail Without Clarity

SMART goals—Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Relevant, Time-bound—work well when you know exactly what you want. Frameworks like OKRs also assume a clear destination. "Become a senior product manager at a mid-size tech company within 3 years" is a perfectly SMART goal.

But if you're uncertain about your direction, specific goals can lead you astray. You might achieve the goal only to discover it wasn't what you wanted. Or you might cling to an arbitrary target because you committed to it, even as you gather evidence it's wrong.

When you don't know where you're going, directional goals serve you better than specific destinations.

The Directional Goal Framework

A directional goal defines the type of movement you want without specifying the exact endpoint:

Instead of: "Become a marketing director at a Fortune 500 company" Try: "Move toward work with more strategic influence and creative expression"

Instead of: "Get promoted to VP of Engineering" Try: "Explore whether I want to grow deeper technically or move into people leadership"

Instead of: "Launch my own startup within 2 years" Try: "Test my appetite and aptitude for entrepreneurship through side projects and small bets"

Directional goals give you:

• A compass, not a GPS: You know which way to walk without knowing the exact destination
• Permission to explore: The goal includes learning and discovery, not just achievement
• Flexibility to adjust: As you learn more, you can refine direction without "failing" at a specific target

Combining Direction with Experiments

Directional goals pair powerfully with the two-year experiment framework:

1. Set a direction: "I want to explore whether work focused on sustainability and environmental impact would energize me"

2. Design experiments that test the direction:

   • Informational interviews with people in climate tech
   • Volunteer project with an environmental nonprofit
   • Online courses in sustainability or environmental science
   • Side project applying your skills to an environmental problem

3. Define what you're trying to learn:

   • Do I find the problems genuinely interesting?
   • Do I connect with the people in this space?
   • Is there a viable career path I can see myself on?
   • Does the work energize or drain me?

4. Evaluate and refine:

   • After 6 months, what have I learned?
   • Should I continue deeper in this direction?
   • Should I adjust to a related direction?
   • Should I pivot to test a different direction entirely?

Informational Interviews and Mentorship

The Power of Conversations

You can read about a career, but you can't truly understand it until you talk to people living it. Informational interviews—conversations with people in roles or fields you're curious about—are the most underrated career exploration tool.

What informational interviews reveal:

• What the day-to-day work actually looks like (not the glamorized version)
• How people got to their current role (usually not the official path)
• What they love and hate about their work
• Advice they'd give their younger selves
• Hidden challenges and hidden rewards
• Whether you connect with people in this field

How to request informational interviews:

1. Be specific about why you're reaching out to them specifically
2. Be clear that you're seeking advice, not asking for a job
3. Respect their time—ask for 20-30 minutes
4. Make it easy to say yes (offer to meet at their convenience, video call if easier)

Sample outreach:

"Hi [Name], I'm currently exploring a potential move into [field/role], and your path from [their background] to [their current role] particularly resonates with my situation. I'm not looking for a job—I'm gathering perspectives to inform my direction. Would you have 20 minutes for a phone call to share your experience? I'd be grateful for any insights you're willing to share."

Finding Mentors When You Don't Know What You Want

Traditional mentorship assumes you know your direction and seek guidance on how to get there. When you're still exploring, you need a different kind of mentor—or more accurately, multiple types of mentors:

Career advisors: People who can help you think through your exploration process itself, regardless of specific field

Domain experts: People deep in fields you're exploring who can tell you what it's really like

Life stage mentors: People who've navigated similar life transitions (career change, uncertainty, starting over) and can speak to the emotional and practical challenges

Skill mentors: People who can help you develop specific capabilities that might be useful across multiple directions

Don't look for one mentor to do it all. Build a personal board of advisors with different perspectives and expertise.

The Value of Reverse Mentorship

While you're exploring, you have something valuable to offer: fresh perspective. People deep in their careers often lose sight of what it's like to be early in the journey. Your questions, challenges, and observations can be genuinely valuable to senior professionals.

Frame relationships as mutual exchanges rather than one-way asks. What can you offer in return? Fresh market research, technology insights, connections to your own network, simply the energy of engaging with someone excited about their field.

Building Career Capital While Exploring

The Danger of Endless Exploration

Exploration is valuable, but it has a shadow side: using "I'm still figuring things out" as an excuse for drift. At some point, you need to commit and build.

The key is building career capital even while exploring—developing assets that will serve you regardless of which direction you ultimately choose.

What Is Career Capital?

Cal Newport, in So Good They Can't Ignore You, defines career capital as the rare and valuable skills that serve as currency in the job market. The more career capital you accumulate, the more control you have over your career—more options, better conditions, greater leverage.

Career capital includes:

• Valuable skills: Capabilities that are both rare and in demand
• Credentials: Degrees, certifications, and recognized achievements
• Track record: A history of results and accomplishments
• Reputation: What you're known for professionally
• Network: Relationships that can create opportunities
• Financial cushion: Resources that give you freedom to take risks

Building Transferable Career Capital

Some career capital is domain-specific—if you leave the field, it doesn't transfer. Other career capital travels with you. While exploring, prioritize transferable capital:

Skills that transfer everywhere:

• Clear communication (written and verbal)
• Project management and execution
• Problem-solving and critical thinking
• Working with data and making decisions
• Leading and influencing others
• Learning quickly

Relationship capital:

• Diverse network across industries and functions
• Reputation for being competent, reliable, and good to work with
• Strong references and advocates

Flexibility capital:

• Financial cushion that allows career risks
• Geographic or lifestyle flexibility
• Skills that apply across contexts

Strategic Skill Building During Exploration

Even without a clear direction, you can strategically develop skills:

1. Identify the overlap: What skills appear in multiple directions you're considering? Develop those first.

2. Build T-shaped expertise: Develop broad competence across many areas and deep expertise in a few high-value skills.

3. Stack unique combinations: Sometimes career differentiation comes not from being the best at one thing, but from combining skills in unusual ways. A data analyst who can also write compelling narratives. An engineer who can also sell.

4. Document as you go: Track your projects, results, and learnings. This becomes evidence for future opportunities.

When to Commit vs. Keep Exploring

The Commitment Question

At some point, exploration must give way to commitment. You can't prototype forever. But how do you know when you've explored enough?

There's no perfect answer, but here are signals that it's time to commit:

Signals you're ready to commit:

• You've genuinely tested multiple directions (not just thought about them)
• One direction clearly energizes you more than others
• You can articulate specific reasons why this path fits your values, skills, and interests
• The remaining uncertainty feels manageable rather than paralyzing
• You've talked to enough people in the field to have realistic expectations
• Your gut says yes (intuition synthesizes more data than conscious analysis)

Signals you should keep exploring:

• You've only explored options intellectually without real-world testing
• No direction stands out—they all feel equally "meh"
• Your uncertainty stems from lack of information, not inherent unpredictability
• You're making decisions based primarily on external validation (prestige, salary, others' expectations)
• Your gut is screaming no and you're trying to logic your way past it

Commitment Doesn't Mean Forever

Here's the liberating truth: committing to a direction doesn't mean marrying it. It means giving it a genuine shot for a defined period—your two-year experiment.

Commitment with an expiration date is easier than commitment forever. You're not choosing your whole future. You're choosing your next chapter and preserving the right to choose differently later.

When Exploration Becomes Avoidance

Sometimes "I'm still figuring things out" is genuine exploration. Sometimes it's fear dressed up as wisdom.

Ask yourself honestly:

• Am I gathering new information, or am I rehashing the same considerations?
• Am I avoiding commitment because I lack data, or because commitment feels scary?
• Would more exploration actually help, or am I using it to postpone risk?
• What's the worst that happens if I commit to a direction and it's wrong?

Often, the worst case is you learn a lot, develop skills, and gain clearer direction—which is exactly what exploration was supposed to accomplish anyway.

Practical Exercises to Try This Week

Day 1: Values Clarification

1. Review the values list earlier in this article
2. Select your top 10 values
3. Force-rank them into a priority order
4. For your top 5, write one sentence about what each means to you specifically
5. Time: 30-45 minutes

Day 2: Energy Audit

1. Review the past month of your work life
2. List 5 activities that energized you
3. List 5 activities that drained you
4. Look for patterns—what do the energizing activities have in common? The draining ones?
5. Time: 20-30 minutes

Day 3: Skills Inventory

1. List your technical skills, transferable skills, and self-management skills
2. Star the skills where you're genuinely strong
3. Circle the skills you enjoy using
4. Note where stars and circles overlap
5. Time: 30-45 minutes

Day 4: Ikigai Mapping

1. Draw four overlapping circles on a large piece of paper
2. Fill in: What you love, What you're good at, What the world needs, What you can be paid for
3. Look for overlaps and gaps
4. Note which gaps represent development opportunities
5. Time: 45-60 minutes

Day 5: Odyssey Plans

1. Design three different five-year scenarios for your life (following the Burnett and Evans approach from Designing Your Life)
2. Make them genuinely different—not three variations of the same theme
3. For each, note: What's your confidence it will work? What resources would you need? What do you like and dislike about it?
4. Time: 60-90 minutes

Day 6: Informational Interview Outreach

1. Identify 5 people in fields or roles you're curious about
2. Draft personalized outreach messages to each
3. Send the messages
4. Time: 45-60 minutes

Day 7: Reflection and Next Steps

1. Review what you learned this week
2. What surprised you?
3. What directions feel most promising?
4. What would you need to learn next to gain more clarity?
5. Design your next experiment
6. Time: 30-45 minutes

Frequently Asked Questions

How do I set career goals when I don't know what I want?

Start with values and energy, not job titles. Identify what matters most to you (autonomy, impact, creativity, stability) and what activities energize versus drain you. Then run small experiments—freelance projects, informational interviews, volunteering—to test directions before committing. You do not need a clear destination to start moving.

Is it too late to change careers?

No. Career changes are increasingly common at every age. The key is building transferable career capital—skills like communication, project management, and problem-solving that apply across fields. Many successful career changers find that their previous experience gives them a unique advantage in their new direction.

How long should I explore before committing to a career path?

Set a time-bound exploration period of 3-6 months for active experimentation. If you are 70% confident in a direction after genuine testing, that is typically enough to commit. Waiting for 100% certainty means waiting indefinitely. Commitment does not mean forever—it means giving a direction a genuine shot.

What if I pick the wrong career path?

The "wrong" career path still teaches you valuable skills, builds your network, and clarifies what you actually want. Most professionals change careers multiple times. Treat career decisions as experiments with a defined duration rather than permanent, irreversible choices.

Should I follow my passion or be practical?

Neither extreme works well. Pure passion without market demand leads to frustration. Pure practicality without engagement leads to burnout. Look for the overlap: work that genuinely interests you and that the market values. Build skills in areas where your curiosity and market demand intersect.

How do I create a career roadmap without a clear destination?

Focus on building transferable career capital rather than following a fixed path. Set short-term goals around skill development, networking, and experimentation rather than specific job titles. Our guide on creating a career roadmap covers this in detail.

Tools for Career Exploration

Find direction and set goals with these free tools:

• Career Roadmap Planner - Explore potential career paths
• SMART Goal Validator - Turn directional goals into specific targets

Moving Forward Without a Map

Not knowing what you want doesn't mean you're lost. It means you're in the discovery phase—a legitimate and valuable part of career development that most advice skips over.

The path forward isn't to wait for clarity to strike. It's to create clarity through action:

• Explore multiple directions through low-cost experiments
• Discover your values, skills, and energy patterns through reflection
• Test your assumptions through conversations and prototypes
• Commit when you've gathered enough data, even without perfect certainty
• Iterate based on what you learn, treating your career as an ongoing experiment

You don't need to find your passion. You don't need a 10-year plan. You don't need career test results to tell you who you are.

You need to start moving—directionally, experimentally, with curiosity and without judgment. The clarity you're seeking is on the other side of action.

Your career isn't a destination to reach. It's a life to design.

---

This guide draws heavily on the work of Bill Burnett and Dave Evans, particularly their book Designing Your Life: How to Build a Well-Lived, Joyful Life. Their Stanford course of the same name has helped thousands of students and professionals navigate career uncertainty. For deeper exploration, we highly recommend reading the full book and completing the exercises they provide.

Related Articles

Guide

Remote Work Productivity: Structuring Your Day Without an Office

Discover how to structure your remote workday with proven routines, boundaries, and habits that make working from home both sustainable and productive.

Jan 5, 202624 min read

Guide

Measuring Productivity: What Matters, What Doesn't, and How to Improve

Learn what to actually measure to boost productivity and what to ignore. Discover evidence-based strategies for meaningful improvement.

Jan 2, 202612 min read

Guide

The Side Project Framework: Building Something Meaningful in 5 Hours a Week

Discover the proven framework busy professionals use to build meaningful side projects in just 5 focused hours per week. Start building now.

Dec 28, 202525 min read

View all articles