The New Manager's Goal-Setting Playbook: First 90 Days

You got the promotion. Congratulations. Now the real work starts.

The shift from individual contributor to new manager is one of the hardest transitions in any career. The skills that got you promoted—deep technical knowledge, personal execution, independent problem-solving—are not the same skills that will make you a successful leader. And goal setting as a manager looks nothing like goal setting as an IC.

Here's the uncomfortable truth: roughly 60% of new managers underperform in their first two years, according to research from CEB (now Gartner). The primary reason? They fail to set clear goals—for themselves, their team, and their relationship with their own boss.

This playbook gives you a structured 90-day framework to avoid that fate. No abstract leadership theory. No motivational fluff. Just a concrete, phase-by-phase plan for setting the right goals at the right time during your first three months as a manager.

Why Goal Setting Changes When You Become a Manager

As an individual contributor, your goals were personal. Ship the feature. Close the deal. Finish the report. You controlled the inputs and the outputs. Success was straightforward.

As a manager, your success is no longer about what you produce. It is about what your team produces. That fundamental shift changes everything about how you set, track, and achieve goals.

Your Output Is Now Your Team's Output

This is the single hardest mental shift for new managers. Your performance review will not ask what you personally built. It will ask what your team delivered.

That means your goals need to focus on:

• Team outcomes, not personal tasks
• Enabling others, not doing it yourself
• Removing blockers, not being the hero
• Building systems, not firefighting

Two Categories of Goals You Need

Every new manager needs goals in two distinct categories:

1. Team goals: What your team will accomplish together. These are the outcomes your boss and the organization are measuring.
2. Personal development goals: The management skills you need to build. Delegation, coaching, conflict resolution, strategic thinking—none of these came naturally to you as an IC.

Most new managers focus entirely on team goals and ignore personal development. That is a mistake. You cannot lead effectively if you are not actively building leadership skills. If you are unsure where to start with your own career goals, take time to define them before your first week on the job.

Days 1-30: Listen, Learn, and Diagnose

Your first month is not about making changes. It is about understanding what you are working with. New managers who charge in with big plans during week one almost always create unnecessary resistance and miss critical context.

Week 1: Understand the Landscape

Your first week has one objective: learn how things actually work.

Milestones for Week 1:

• Hold individual 30-minute introductions with every direct report
• Identify your team's current active goals and projects
• Map your key stakeholders (boss, peers, cross-functional partners)
• Review existing team metrics and dashboards
• Read the last two quarters of team performance data

In those introductory conversations, ask every direct report these five questions:

1. What is going well on the team that I should not change?
2. What is the biggest challenge you face in doing your best work?
3. What would you change about how the team operates?
4. What do you need from me as your manager?
5. What should I know that nobody will tell me unprompted?

Write down every answer. Patterns will emerge fast.

Weeks 2-3: Diagnose Team Health

Now dig deeper. You are looking for gaps between where the team is and where it needs to be.

Assess these dimensions:

• Goal clarity: Does everyone know what the team is trying to achieve? Can each person articulate how their work connects to team objectives?
• Skill gaps: Where is the team strong? Where is it weak? Are people in the right roles?
• Process health: Are standups, planning sessions, and reviews working? Or are they performative?
• Morale and trust: Do people trust each other? Do they trust leadership? Is there unaddressed conflict?
• Stakeholder alignment: Do your peers and boss have the same expectations for your team that you do?

Week 4: Set Your 90-Day Diagnostic Goals

By the end of month one, you should be able to articulate:

• The team's three biggest strengths
• The team's three biggest problems
• Your boss's top three expectations for you this quarter
• The one quick win you can deliver in month two

Document these findings. Share them with your boss. Ask: "Does this match your read on the situation?" This conversation is critical—it ensures you are solving the right problems before you start setting team goals.

Learning how to align your goals with your manager's expectations is one of the most important skills you will develop as a new leader.

Days 31-60: Align, Set Goals, and Score Quick Wins

Month two is where you shift from observation to action. You have the data. Now build the plan.

Setting Team Goals That Actually Work

Your team goals should follow a simple structure. If you want a proven framework, OKRs (Objectives and Key Results) are the gold standard for team goal setting.

Here is the process:

Step 1: Start with your boss's priorities. Your team goals must connect to what your boss and organization care about. If your boss needs revenue growth and your team goals focus on internal tooling, you have a disconnect.

Step 2: Translate organizational priorities into team-level objectives. Take the big-picture goals and make them specific to your team's scope. "Grow revenue 20%" becomes "Increase conversion rate on the checkout flow from 3.2% to 4.5%."

Step 3: Involve your team in defining key results. People commit to goals they help create. Share the objectives and ask your team: "What specific outcomes would tell us we achieved this?" Let them define the measurable targets.

Step 4: Limit to 3-5 objectives per quarter. More than five team objectives creates diffusion. Your team cannot focus on everything. Ruthless prioritization is your job now.

Example: New Manager's Team OKRs

Here is what a realistic set of team OKRs might look like for a new engineering manager:

Objective 1: Improve product reliability

• Key Result: Reduce P1 incidents from 4/month to 1/month
• Key Result: Increase test coverage from 62% to 80%
• Key Result: Reduce average incident resolution time from 4 hours to 90 minutes

Objective 2: Accelerate feature delivery

• Key Result: Ship 3 planned features by end of quarter
• Key Result: Reduce average cycle time from 14 days to 8 days
• Key Result: Complete sprint commitments in 80%+ of sprints

Objective 3: Build a stronger team

• Key Result: Complete career development conversations with all 6 direct reports
• Key Result: Fill the open senior engineer role by week 10
• Key Result: Achieve team engagement score of 4.0+ (currently 3.4)

Notice each objective has measurable key results. No vague "improve quality" or "ship faster." Specific numbers. Specific deadlines. If you want to learn more about writing OKRs that actually drive results, we have a deep-dive guide on that.

Setting Personal Management Goals

Do not skip this. Your personal development as a manager matters as much as your team's output.

Personal OKRs for a new manager (month 2-3):

Objective: Become an effective people manager

• Key Result: Hold weekly 1:1s with every direct report for 8 consecutive weeks
• Key Result: Deliver meaningful feedback (both positive and constructive) to each team member at least twice
• Key Result: Delegate at least 2 tasks I would have done myself as an IC
• Key Result: Complete one management book or course

Objective: Build strong stakeholder relationships

• Key Result: Have alignment conversations with all 4 peer managers
• Key Result: Establish a biweekly check-in cadence with my boss
• Key Result: Identify and resolve 1 cross-team dependency or conflict

These personal goals keep you honest about your own growth. Without them, you will default to IC habits—doing the work instead of leading the team.

Identifying and Delivering Quick Wins

Quick wins matter disproportionately in your first 90 days. They build credibility with your team, your boss, and your peers.

What makes a good quick win:

• Visible to the team and stakeholders
• Achievable within 2-4 weeks
• Addresses a real pain point (not a vanity project)
• Does not require major organizational change
• Demonstrates that you listened during month one

Examples of strong quick wins:

• Fix the broken CI/CD pipeline that has annoyed the team for months
• Cancel the meeting everyone hates but no one has been empowered to remove
• Resolve the long-standing dispute with the design team about handoff process
• Get budget approval for a tool the team has been requesting

Examples of bad quick wins:

• Reorganize the entire team structure
• Rewrite the codebase architecture
• Change the team's methodology (Scrum to Kanban or vice versa)
• Fire someone in your first month

Quick wins should prove that you listened, that you act, and that you care about the team's day-to-day experience.

Days 61-90: Execute, Build Rhythm, and Course-Correct

Month three is about execution and establishing the operating cadence you will run for the next year.

Building Your Management Operating System

By day 61, you need a repeatable weekly and monthly rhythm. This is your management operating system.

Weekly rhythm:

Monthly rhythm:

• Week 1: Team retrospective on previous month
• Week 2: Goal progress review (are we on track?)
• Week 3: Individual career development conversations
• Week 4: Planning and priority-setting for next month

This rhythm creates predictability. Your team knows when they will get your attention. Your boss knows when to expect updates. You know when to step back and think strategically.

Tracking Progress Without Micromanaging

New managers often swing between two extremes: ignoring progress entirely or checking in so frequently they become micromanagers.

The middle ground is structured visibility. Set up systems that let you see progress without hovering over your team.

Practical approaches:

• Shared goal dashboard: Use a tool where the team updates their own progress. Beyond Time, for example, lets each person track milestones against shared objectives.
• Weekly written updates: Ask each team member for a brief weekly update (3-5 bullets: what they did, what they are doing next, what is blocking them). Read them. Respond when needed.
• Goal check-ins during 1:1s: Dedicate the first 5 minutes of each 1:1 to reviewing progress on that person's key results. Not interrogating—reviewing.

The goal is to catch problems early without creating a surveillance culture. If someone is falling behind, you want to know in week two—not week eight.

Course-Correcting Goals Mid-Quarter

Your initial goals will not all be right. That is normal, especially in your first quarter as a manager.

Signs you need to adjust goals:

• External circumstances changed (reorg, budget cut, new priority from leadership)
• A goal was too aggressive or too conservative based on new information
• The team discovered a critical problem that was not on the radar
• A key team member left or joined

How to course-correct well:

1. Acknowledge the change openly. Do not pretend the original goal still applies if it does not.
2. Explain why the adjustment is needed. Connect it to new information, not to failure.
3. Involve the team in resetting targets. They will have the best view on what is realistic.
4. Communicate the change to your boss before they discover it themselves.

The 12-week year approach is helpful here. Treating your quarter as a complete planning cycle—not a slice of an annual plan—gives you permission to adjust without feeling like you failed.

The New Manager's OKR Framework

OKRs are particularly powerful for new managers because they separate the "what" (objectives) from the "how" (key results) and create clarity for everyone.

How to Structure Team OKRs vs. Personal OKRs

You need both. Here is how they differ:

Team OKR Best Practices for New Managers

Keep it simple. Your first quarter, aim for 2-3 team objectives. Not 5. Not 7. Two or three, with 2-4 key results each. If you are new to structured goal setting, start with the basics before layering on management-specific frameworks. You can add complexity later once the team has the muscle memory.

Make objectives inspiring but achievable. Stretch goals are fine for established teams. For a team with a brand-new manager, prioritize building confidence through achievable goals over ambitious moonshots.

Tie every objective to a stakeholder need. For each objective, you should be able to answer: "Who outside this team cares about this, and why?" If you cannot answer that, the objective may not be the right priority.

Review progress weekly, not quarterly. OKRs that get reviewed once a quarter are just New Year's resolutions for teams. Use your weekly standup to check in on key results. A five-minute pulse check keeps goals alive.

Use our free OKR Generator to draft your first set of team and personal OKRs.

Common New Manager Mistakes (and How Goals Prevent Them)

Every new manager makes mistakes. But having clear goals reduces the worst ones. Here are the traps and how goal-setting protects you.

Mistake 1: Doing Everyone's Job

When you see a problem, your IC instinct is to fix it yourself. You know how. It will be faster. The quality will be higher.

This is the most dangerous habit a new manager can carry forward.

When you do the work yourself, three bad things happen:

• Your team does not learn or grow
• You have no time for actual management work (coaching, planning, unblocking)
• You create a dependency where the team waits for you instead of acting independently

Goal-based fix: Set a personal OKR to delegate a specific number of tasks per week. Track it. When you catch yourself picking up someone else's task, stop and ask: "Who on my team should own this, and what do they need from me to succeed?"

Mistake 2: Avoiding Difficult Conversations

New managers often avoid giving constructive feedback because they want to be liked. They let performance issues fester. They accept mediocre work to keep the peace.

This backfires within months. High performers leave because they see low performers being tolerated. Standards erode. The team culture deteriorates.

Goal-based fix: Include a key result for feedback delivery in your personal OKRs. "Deliver constructive feedback to at least 2 team members by end of month." When it is a goal, you treat it like any other deliverable.

Mistake 3: No Personal Development Goals

Many new managers are so focused on the team that they forget to invest in themselves. They learn by trial and error—which means they repeat mistakes that others have already solved.

Goal-based fix: Dedicate at least one personal OKR to your own growth. Reading, courses, mentoring, peer learning. Put it on the same tracking system as your team goals. Your development is not optional.

Mistake 4: Setting Goals in Isolation

Some new managers set team goals without involving the team. They announce objectives top-down and expect compliance. This creates resentment and kills ownership.

Goal-based fix: Make collaborative goal-setting a process, not an event. Bring draft objectives to the team. Ask for input on key results. Let people volunteer for ownership. When people help create the goals, they commit to achieving them.

Mistake 5: Ignoring Upward Alignment

You have a boss too. If your team goals do not connect to what your boss and the organization need, you will be working hard on the wrong things.

Goal-based fix: Before finalizing any team objective, validate it with your boss. Ask: "If my team achieves this, will you consider this quarter a success?" If the answer is hesitant, you need to adjust.

Building Your Management Routine

Goals without routines are wishes. Your management routine is the engine that turns goals into results.

The Weekly 1:1 Structure

Your most important recurring meeting is the 1:1 with each direct report. Use a simple 30-minute structure:

• First 5 minutes: Goal progress check. Review their key results. Ask what is blocking them.
• Next 10 minutes: Their agenda. Let them bring topics, questions, concerns. Listen more than you talk.
• Next 10 minutes: Your agenda. Share context from leadership. Provide feedback. Discuss development.
• Last 5 minutes: Action items. Summarize commitments on both sides.

Hold these weekly. Do not cancel them. If you must reschedule, do it within the same week. Cancelling 1:1s repeatedly tells your team they are not important to you.

The Weekly Team Sync

Keep it short—30 minutes maximum. Cover three things:

1. Progress on team OKRs (5 minutes): Quick round-robin on key results
2. Blockers and decisions (15 minutes): What needs to be resolved this week?
3. Announcements and context (10 minutes): Share what is happening at the org level

Do not use team meetings for status updates that could be written. If someone's update is "I'm working on X," that belongs in Slack or a written update, not a meeting.

The Monthly Goal Review

Once a month, step back and look at the bigger picture:

• Are we on track for our quarterly objectives?
• Which key results are ahead? Which are behind?
• What has changed in our environment that affects our goals?
• Do any goals need to be adjusted, dropped, or added?

Document the review. Share it with your boss. This monthly cadence prevents the "oh no, it's end of quarter and we forgot about our OKRs" problem that plagues most teams.

For a detailed guide on running effective weekly reviews, see our complete guide to weekly reviews.

Your 90-Day Goal-Setting Checklist

Here is the full checklist, organized by phase. Print it. Put it on your wall. Check items off as you complete them.

Days 1-30: Listen and Learn

• Hold introductory 1:1s with all direct reports
• Map stakeholders (boss, peers, cross-functional partners)
• Review last two quarters of team performance data
• Identify team's top 3 strengths and top 3 problems
• Hold alignment conversation with your boss
• Identify one quick win to pursue in month two

Days 31-60: Align and Set

• Draft 2-3 team OKRs for the quarter
• Involve team in refining key results
• Set 2-3 personal management development OKRs
• Validate team goals with your boss
• Deliver your quick win
• Establish weekly 1:1 cadence with all direct reports
• Establish weekly team sync meeting

Days 61-90: Execute and Adjust

• Run full weekly management rhythm for 4+ weeks
• Conduct first monthly goal review
• Course-correct at least one goal based on new information
• Deliver feedback (positive and constructive) to every direct report
• Hold career development conversations with each team member
• Prepare end-of-quarter review for your boss
• Plan next quarter's OKRs based on what you learned

Use a quarter planner to map these milestones to specific weeks and ensure nothing falls through the cracks.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do I set goals for a team I just inherited?

Start by understanding the team's current goals and how they were performing before you arrived. Spend your first 30 days listening—hold 1:1s, review past performance data, and talk to stakeholders. Avoid changing goals in your first month unless something is clearly broken. By day 31-45, you should have enough context to collaboratively set new goals with the team that align with organizational priorities.

Should new managers use OKRs or another goal-setting framework?

OKRs work exceptionally well for new managers because they separate the inspirational "what" (Objectives) from the measurable "how" (Key Results). This structure forces clarity. That said, the specific framework matters less than the habit. Whether you use OKRs, SMART goals, or a simpler milestone-based approach, the key is having written, measurable goals that you review regularly. Our guide on OKRs covers the framework in detail.

What is the biggest mistake new managers make with goal setting?

The biggest mistake is setting goals for the team without involving the team. Top-down goals create compliance, not commitment. The second most common mistake is failing to set personal development goals for themselves. You cannot coast on IC skills. Management requires new capabilities—delegation, coaching, strategic thinking—that must be developed intentionally.

How many goals should a new manager set in their first quarter?

Keep it focused: 2-3 team objectives with 2-4 key results each, plus 2-3 personal development objectives. That is roughly 6-8 total goals across both categories. New managers who set 10+ goals in their first quarter almost always fail to make meaningful progress on any of them. Fewer goals, deeper execution.

How do I balance my own goals with my team's goals?

Use the 80/20 principle. Spend roughly 80% of your management time on team-facing activities—1:1s, coaching, planning, unblocking, stakeholder management. Reserve 20% for personal development—reading, courses, reflection, mentoring. Block the personal development time on your calendar. If you do not protect it, team demands will consume 100% of your time.

When should I adjust goals mid-quarter?

Adjust when the underlying assumptions change—a team member leaves, priorities shift from above, or you discover that a goal was set based on incomplete information. Do not adjust because things are hard. Difficulty is expected. Adjust when the goal itself is wrong, not when the execution is challenging. When you do adjust, communicate the change transparently to your team and your boss.

How do I manage up effectively as a new manager?

Proactive communication is the foundation. Send your boss a brief weekly update covering team progress, risks, and decisions you need from them. Ask for explicit expectations in your first month: "What does success look like for me and my team this quarter?" Validate your goals before finalizing them. And flag problems early—bosses hate surprises. For a comprehensive guide, read our article on managing up and aligning goals with your manager.

Your First 90 Days Start Now

The transition from individual contributor to manager is not about working harder. It is about working differently. The goals you set in your first 90 days will determine whether you build a high-performing team or spend your first year putting out fires.

Here is what matters most:

Month 1: Listen. Learn. Diagnose. Do not change anything until you understand the current state.

Month 2: Set goals collaboratively—team OKRs and personal development OKRs. Score a quick win. Start your 1:1 cadence.

Month 3: Execute your management rhythm. Track progress. Course-correct. Prepare for your next quarter.

The best managers are not the smartest people in the room. They are the ones who set clear goals, build strong routines, and relentlessly focus on making their team better.

You have 90 days. Make them count.

Free Tools to Help You Set Management Goals

• OKR Generator - Draft your first set of team and personal OKRs in minutes
• Quarter Planner - Map your 90-day milestones to specific weeks
• AI Milestone Generator - Break down big management goals into actionable steps

Related Articles

Guide

Is Your Goal SMART Enough? How to Test and Improve Any Goal

Use the SMART framework to transform vague intentions into achievable goals. Test yours with our free validator and see exactly what's missing.

Feb 8, 202623 min read

Guide

How to Set Health and Fitness Goals That Actually Stick

Stop setting vague fitness goals. Learn to create specific, measurable health goals with habit systems that survive motivation dips and busy seasons.

Feb 5, 202622 min read

Guide

How to Write OKRs That Actually Drive Results (+ Free Generator)

Master writing personal OKRs with proven formulas and real examples. Use our free AI OKR generator to create aligned objectives and key results.

Feb 5, 202622 min read

View all articles